From the storming of the heavens to the Pax Trumpiana: ten years of capitalist progress
Download here
It is well known, inside and outside the “militant world,” that the axis of bourgeois politics has shifted over the last decade. The era of the wave of mobilizations that began in 2011 was used as fuel by a new generation on the left who, under democratic and citizenist premises, sought to prove to the world that States could be governed differently. Somehow, that instrument that is the State could be directed toward satisfying the interests of the social majorities, of those from below —to quote some of their expressions— if it was in the right hands.
The year 2015 was a turning point for this “new” left, with Syriza winning the elections in Greece and entering the front lines of bourgeois politics, alongside groups like Podemos in Spain or the M5S in Italy, as well as the rise of DSA in the United States. For the first time in recent times, the sectors of capital situated to the left of social democracy found themselves facing the possibility of democratically challenging its position as the recuperator of social conflict. This meant, therefore, that the eternal opposition to the mainstream left and right came to manage the institutions for the first time, buoyed by the hopes of broad sectors of the population.
The Greek case was the litmus test for this “new” left. The two elections held that year resulted in sweeping victories for Syriza, which, with its leader Alexis Tsipras as prime minister, fancied its chances against what the troika—European Union, ECB, and IMF—ordered from Brussels. The new government’s first step, supported by the radical right of ANEL, was to resort to the old nationalism to mobilize the Greeks in a referendum to reject these impositions, even putting the possibility of leaving the euro on the table. Despite the success of this referendum, it was the Syriza government that was tasked with implementing all of the EU reforms on the battered Greek economy. No one in those spaces could explain how this had happened, weren’t they going to slam a fist on the table, to put in their proper place those gray European bureaucrats?
The “new” left discovered that the State was not the neutral machine they thought it was, but rather demanded the satisfaction of certain needs—those of the economy—which, at this point in capitalist development, know only one single path: privatization and liberalization, greedily slashing spending on healthcare and education. However, these cuts were not replicated in the military sphere, out of fear of stirring up their right-wing partners. The fulfillment of these mandates, which claimed the head of one of the emblems of this new left—that of Economy Minister Yannis Varoufakis—, was carried out with an efficiency and in an atmosphere of social peace that the governments—conservative and social-democratic—that preceded Tsipras’s could never have imagined. In short, the “new” left was always the old politics of the bourgeoisie, as it demonstrated from the very beginning with its recourse to the same old nationalist rhetoric.
In Spain, although in a different way, a similar experience occurred with Podemos. This party, founded in 2014 by a group of university professors and by the organization of Trotskyist origin Izquierda Anticapitalista (currently Anticapitalistas), was able to channel the hopes of broad sectors of the population, exhausted after years of cuts and austerity imposed by the PSOE and PP governments. Its strong performance in the 2014 European elections and in the 2015 general elections, as well as the success of its municipal platforms in that same year—which won cities like Madrid, Barcelona, Zaragoza, or Cádiz—led many to believe that, as in Greece, the space to the left of social democracy could unseat it from its dominant position on the political spectrum. It is to them that credit belongs for reintroducing into that space of Spanish politics signifiers that had been taboo during the preceding 40 years, such as homeland or nation1.
However, and as in the Greek case, the result of their foray into municipal and national politics could be none other than the perpetuation of the reforms implemented by previous governments, both in the economic realm—such as the labor reform implemented by the sector of the government belonging to Sumar, a reinvention of the Podemos space, the evictions that they were supposedly going to prevent banks from carrying out, or the increase in military spending—and in the social realm—maintaining the Gag Law passed by the PP, or infiltrating agents of the police into various social groups—. The storming of the heavens ended up turning into complicity with the police repression in the jumping of the fence in Melilla in June of 2022, which ended with at least 37 migrants murdered, or with the increase in military spending to drag the proletarians into the war against Russia, against China or against whoever is necessary in order to keep afloat—or try to—the share of the pie of the exploitation of the proletariat corresponding to the Spanish bourgeoisie, subordinated in turn to the French and German ones. Once again, the “new” left, those who were going to turn the State into an entity at the service of our needs thanks to their university knowledge, ended up engaging in politics as usual, subjected to the needs of national capital. Nonetheless, despite having institutionally channeled the anger of broad sectors of the population for a few years, their frustration continues, insofar as their demands remain as unsatisfied as they were ten years ago.
A rigorous analysis of these processes, however, will allow us to see that not all the proposals put forward by this current during its periods in power—they still remain there, in the case of Sumar—have become a dead letter. Some ideas that until then were on the margins of political debate, such as feminism or environmentalism, have become part of the mainstream. In other words, feminism and environmentalism have become, for both their defenders and their detractors, State ideologies. Numerous initiatives and laws have been carried out during this decade with the expectation of abolishing or, at least, mitigating the effects of patriarchy in society through institutional channels. However, a greater judicialization of gender-based violence, the modification of the gender recorded before the State, or the inclusion in the Constitution of the right to abortion (in the same ornamental section where the right to a decent wage and housing is mentioned) are more useful to the “cultural battle” of the left against the right, the only battle that still serves them to distinguish themselves in the electoral market, than to alleviate the violence, suffering, and inequality that this society inflicts on women, trans people, and the rest of the LGBTI community.
Also approved were numerous initiatives to carry out the so-called “green transition”
—presented across different regions of the world under names such as “Green Deal” or “Green New Deal,” among other pretentious titles—which would consist of a plan to promote the progressive abandonment of dependence on fossil fuels in favor of renewable energy sources, with the necessary escalation in the investments to be able to carry out said change, at the same time as a new “social pact” with redistributive policies and with a boost to the creation of quality jobs. These measures had a certain visibility in the period of economic slowdown experienced in the years 2018 and 2019, as well as during the economic crisis that followed the lockdowns due to the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, generating the occasional speculative bubble and a rather meager amount of jobs. Far from fostering a greater redistribution of wealth and light-years away from giving a new boost to the valorization of capital, as their proponents promised, these measures opened up the prospect of greater pressure on the means of subsistence, promising a new era of green austerity burnished by ecological discourse, without thereby having the capacity to carry out a genuine energy transition. Because there cannot be an energy transition in a mode of production that, because of its need for unlimited growth to produce more and more value, requires an increasing amount of energy and raw materials. In any case, there will be no energy transition but rather a desperate aggregation of various forms of energy production to satisfy —temporarily— the hunger of the machines, while it continues starving the whole of humanity. Renewable energies, it should be said in passing, have physical limits to their productive capacity, in addition to a non-negligible ecological footprint both due to the way they occupy territory and due to the imperative need for minerals they entail.
The COVID-19 pandemic and the start of the Russian invasion of Ukraine were, however, critical moments that began to signal to the bourgeoisie that its future was beginning to head down different paths. The reduction of CO2 emissions has yielded its priority place in public policy to an increase in military spending, as part of an imperialist escalation that has only intensified in recent years: to the aforementioned invasion must be added the bloody resurgences of conflicts such as those of Israel and Palestine, with the extermination suffered by the Gazan population, the displacements and ethnic cleansings in Sudan, or the militaristic realignment of the bourgeoisies of the Sahel —now regional powers— alongside Russia and China and against France, the former colonial power. In these conflicts, the interests of the different imperialisms are settled —the US, China, Russia, Iran— competing for a slice of the pie of our exploitation which, as we have already pointed out, is increasingly smaller. War in Europe, a taboo topic since the end of World War II —Yugoslavia aside—, has become part of everyday political conversation, with our bourgeoisies calling on us to prepare for it, with the constant pressure of a Russian threat, and with the restoration of military service being suggested with increasing insistence, for which they return —inevitably— to the same nationalist rhetoric as always. An example of this shift in priorities was the German foreign ministry, in the hands of the Greens between 2021 and 2025, which distinguished itself by being a hawk in foreign policy toward Russia. The increase in military spending must be understood, for the various European bourgeoisies, as an investment in security, to preserve our “values” and institutions —gone is that talk of the “global village”—. In other words, they are trying to raise military spending against the clock so that it reaches a percentage of GDP somewhat close to that of the major imperialist powers —the US, China, and Russia alone account for 60% of world military spending—. However, these increases have not only taken place in Europe, as if only the European bourgeoisie were imperialist, and a good example of this is the so-called BRICS, taking advantage of their privileged position due to their possession of so-called rare earths.
This context of imperialist escalation is the perfect breeding ground for the rise of nationalist and far-right positions, which present themselves as a false solution to the growing helplessness and social fragmentation that the measures implemented by the “alternative” lefts could not prevent. While behind the rejection of environmentalism lies a deep distrust that these measures will actually remedy the worsening of living conditions, and it is clearly perceived how capital pits the conservation of nature against the conservation of material living conditions, behind virilism and antifeminism lies a reaction to the breakdown of traditional models of the family and of femininity/masculinity, which are accompanied by social atomization, the dissolution of the protective barriers against a hostile world that the traditional family used to provide, and in general the reaction to a deep crisis of identity that leaves an anguished void for anyone who does not envision an emancipatory horizon before them. All that is solid melts into air, but in the absence of class struggle there is nothing positive to replace it. The reaction against feminism and environmentalism, or against any awareness of specific violence against women and of the climate crisis, has been virulent, but the response has been none other than to radically deny these problems. In other words: there is no answer, because capitalism has no answers to our problems.
The model of political action for these currents, whether in Europe or on the American continent, is a combination of economic nationalism —more or less liberal— and theatrical forcefulness that in the United States have been summarized with great precision in two slogans: the reframed MAGA (for its acronym: make America great again; it has been used intermittently since the 80’s) and the relatively new Peace through strength, which aims to resolve the different imperialist conflicts under the threat of being bombed by the greater imperialism. The best example of this —and, despite the propaganda, the only one— has been the ceasefire in Gaza, in effect since October of 2025, although constantly broken2. The Trump administration pressured Israel to accept the ceasefire and the release of 2,000 Palestinian prisoners, while threatening Hamas with “total extermination” if it did not agree to disarm and release the Israeli hostages. This agreement was finally signed with the support of a large part of the world bourgeoisie, including the ultra-progressive Spanish government. Other attempts at this diplomacy have been made to resolve the conflict between Russia and Ukraine, but the imbalance of forces between the United States and Russia is infinitely smaller than with Israel or Palestine, so it has had no effect, nor does it look likely to do so.
In spite of everything, this rise of the far right should not be taken as a strengthening of the system, but rather, on the contrary, as a sign of its weakness. On the contrary, the new forms of the right are nothing more than an attempt to maintain the function of democratic channels, which is that of channeling social unrest through support for one political force or another through elections, as well as reviving opposition forces (in this case, antifascist). In a context where the conventional left and right are increasingly delegitimized, where the alternative left already had its chance to show that it was good for nothing, the next attempt is these formulas of right-wing populism with which the bourgeoisie itself is not entirely comfortable, because it knows that the need of its exponents to present themselves as outsiders alien to the establishment can lead them to promote measures counterproductive to the interests of national capital, —as occurred with Brexit or can potentially occur with the US trade war with its allies—. It is the price to pay to maintain the main function of the democratic mechanisms, which is the creation of new channels for social unrest when the old ones begin to break down.
The problem is that this price does not end up settling the problem either. On the one hand, because unlike fascism, the far right does not come to provide a national solution that unites most of the bourgeoisie behind the fascist state as occurred in Italy and for a briefer time in Germany, but rather these figures arrive as disruptive elements that accentuate political fractures within the bourgeoisie. They are not agents of unification, but of dissension. On the other hand, because, just as the alternative left quickly revealed itself as a false alternative, the new right cannot halt the worsening of the living conditions of the proletariat either, which is the very source of that unrest. Because of this, they are not elements of strength for the system, but of weakness, of loss of horizon. Nor are they even good instruments at the service of the tendency toward war, because their loose-cannon nature, their erratic policies (like Trump with Russia), and their political excesses with old allies make it difficult to achieve the stability needed to ensure the success of your imperialist bloc against the other.
One proof of this weakness lies, continuing with the US example, in its inability to pay its own employees for a month and a half, despite having the majority in the legislative bodies. Another proof, and this one, at a more general level, lies in the fact that neither the government of the United States, nor that of Argentina, nor those of Italy, Poland, and Hungary can reverse the trends to which capitalism leads: workers have continued losing purchasing power, inequalities have continued growing, and the safeguards or palliatives that were previously granted by states have continued to dissolve. The far right is a giant with feet of clay that, behind the violence —racist, sexist…— and warmongering (fostered, it must be said, by preceding or contemporary left-wing governments), is unable to quell the unrest of a proletariat that no longer has options left to choose from within capitalist social peace. In other words: time passes, and our rage does not stop growing.
It is worth noting that these right-wing populisms emerged at the same time as the “new” lefts of which we spoke at the beginning: out of the rage and frustration at the consequences of the crisis of 2008. The movement from one to the other is not a straight line, but must be understood dialectically, as a process: both coexist even if one predominates at a certain moment. The rise of Podemos, Syriza or M5S was not incompatible with the rise of the National Front, of Lega or of Alternative for Germany, or with Trump’s first presidency. In the same way, the terms of Milei, of Fratelli d’Italia, or Trump’s second term do not prevent expressions from appearing such as the rise of Sinn Féin in Ireland or figures like Mamdani in New York, given the proletariat’s ongoing lack of its own options due to the moment of social peace in which we live. In spite of everything, one thing is clear: there is a search for radicalism among minorities that tends to overflow the limits of this system, and sooner or later, there will be no alliance with the bourgeoisie —conservative or progressive— that can contain it. Whatever configuration the bourgeoisie may take at a given moment, from this we draw an invariant lesson from which to orient ourselves: there is no alternative for the proletariat within the capitalist system; only the world proletarian revolution will free us from our chains.
- This is addressed in greater detail in our booklet on the rise and fall of Podemos, which, although published prior to their entry into the national government, reflects very well the nature of this “new” left in its storming of the heavens.
- And the fact is that nationalism only feeds more nationalism, more death, as we pointed out in our leaflet on Gaza
