LOADING

Type to search

English Other languages

[Transcription] El Programa E10: Class Struggle in the 21st Century

Download PDF

In this new episode of El Programa—the podcast from Grupo Barbaria—we interview a comrade about the various waves of revolt, spanning from the 2000s to the present day. This episode was recorded one day before the events of October 17th (17-O) in France.

Reading materials:

Diez notas sobre la perspectiva revolucionaria

Catástrofe capitalista y teoría revolucionaria

Apuntes sobre nuestro momento histórico

n+1 – Una vida sin sentido

 

Host: Hello and welcome to a new episode of “The Program”, Barbaria’s podcast. In today’s episode we’ll talk about the latest revolts. From Sri Lanka to Hong Kong, from Europe to the USA, and also Iran. We’ve been witnessing for years a series of revolts, struggles or processes in which we’ve seen enormous social combativeness, and in this episode, we’ll take some time to stop, understand and reflect on them.

[Music break]

Well, today we’ll look at the different waves of proletarian class struggle. This century has seen various expressions of it, so we’ll talk about different cycles, and different waves.

The first of them, the one that opened the cycle, was the 2001 revolt in Argentina, with its famous popular assemblies and its slogan “¡Que se vayan todos!” (“All of them must go!”), which spread to many places in Latin America, such as Ecuador and Bolivia, and reached Oaxaca in 2006.

A second wave came onto the scene with the hunger revolts that began in 2008 and peaked in 2011. There was what’s known as the “Arab Spring”, from Tunisia to Tahrir Square, then Syria, but it also had its echo, expansion and its connection in the Spanish 15-M and in Occupy Wall Street in the USA.

Then came waves with increased class violence: the yellow vests, for example, who inaugurated this phenomenon or at least expressed it strongly, and also the revolts in Chile in October 2019, and in Hong Kong too. We could even connect these to the struggles in Ecuador, Colombia and Lebanon, which were facilitated by the financial crisis. This wave was also echoed in Greece, Brazil and Turkey, with the occupation of Gezi Park in Taksim. These are all moments that are getting ever closer together in time, because after the pandemic we saw a fourth wave of revolts, which began with even greater violence. They recently toppled the governments of Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. We also saw the struggle in Kazakhstan, and how that wave connected with the strikes in France, the UK and Greece. We should also remember the example of Kenya.

But an especially strong expression has been Iran, recently, with an incredibly combative proletariat, as always, and with the repression by the ayatollahs’ regime following the death of the young woman brutally murdered by that regime. These struggles spread, and well, this whole series of waves, beyond the general situation of capitalism that explains why they’ve been happening, has an accelerator within the dynamic of class struggle: the contradictions and tensions within capital. These struggles and these waves determine a historical moment, they determine the present situation.

What characterizes our historical moment? Our comrade here will help us understand it.

Guest: Yes, what you were saying sums up quite well a whole series of aspects we’ve been developing over time in Ten Notes on the Revolutionary Perspective, and especially in a more recent booklet we have on the historical moment we’re in. There, we talk about these four waves of struggle that have taken place in the 21st century; we define, or rather list, a whole series of struggles and revolts that are very different from each other.

For example, when we speak of the third cycle of struggles, protests and revolts before COVID, Hong Kong, with its citizenist, democratic and anti-regime perspective, is very different from movements that are far more radical and have a clear class component, like Chile or, earlier, the yellow vests. Furthermore, there’s a text by our comrades of Proletarios Internacionalistas that defines this whole protest cycle very well, the yellow vests for example. It tries to characterize this moment of struggle, and we’ve also published it on our website.

And I think these four waves of struggle help us understand the historical moment we’re living in and how a whole series of aspects are coming about, which I think allow us to establish at least three elements that we can generalize.

Firstly, a subterranean process of maturation of consciousness, and of these historical processes, is taking shape. That is to say, we’re not facing atomized and separate historical processes, as the bourgeoisie likes to think, processes that have nothing to do with each other, either at the moment they occur or when they communicate with each other during the subsequent maturation of consciousness.

It’s very important to understand that what we’re seeing is a cycle of struggles with many elements in common, in which there is a maturation of consciousness about what kind of historical period we’re living in as a proletariat, as a class, as humanity against capital.

Then there’s a whole series of elements we believe they have in common. The occupation of squares, for example, is a constant, ever-present phenomenon since 2001: as you said, in Argentina, with “¡Que se vayan todos!”, and in Oaxaca in 2006, where the Zócalo and a large part of the city was occupied, which was met with fierce repression by the Mexican state. Today we see it again, with differences, in the occupation of roundabouts by the yellow vests or the assemblies that sprang up in Chile; with many differences, in the 15-M at Puerta del Sol; and with other differences again in what’s happening right now in the struggles in Spain.

But there’s an important element for us to consider: how do we bring about a process that breaks with the separation between production and circulation, between the “inside” of the factory and the outside? Struggles that get stuck outside take on a “citizenist” character that is easily recuperable by the institutions. I think of the strength of the struggle in Sudan as an example of this; but at the same time, this citizenist or democratic character of the fight against the regime introduces easily recuperable elements.

But what’s really important is that these kinds of elements, these levels of self-activity and self-organization that take different forms depending on the process, remind us, potentially, like a small fractal, of what the struggle of the proletariat has historically been, through different means of self-organization and self-activity. It’s something always present in these struggles, and it reminds us of what the instruments, the means and the forms of proletarian struggle are whenever it fights.

In many of these protests, the ones that take on the character of a revolt, this element of self-organization is combined with an expansion of the protests. In this expansion, some specific issue may arise, as happened in Chile with the rise in subway fares, but the protest immediately goes beyond it, goes further and keeps expanding (we can go deeper into this later, in other questions maybe). There’s a search for a generalization of content that still clashes with a consciousness trapped in these citizenist-democratic kinds of struggle, trapped inside the world of capital.

Even so, we believe there is a process of maturation in these struggles, of a different relationship to violence and pacifism, for example in the course of the current struggle in France, in these student protests where over 8,000 people have been arrested, or in Chile in 2019. We can see some of these questions in this fourth wave, or, obviously, in the struggles in Indonesia last year, and in Nepal as well; there are countless examples.

But in the burning of the parliament in Indonesia, for example, there’s a really strong dimension of social explosiveness that still lacks a class perspective, or any clear perspective at all. It doesn’t have the perspective of overcoming this historical era, characterized by a hundred years of counterrevolution, and yet it’s an era that is increasingly eroded and in ever deeper crisis. A comrade, in some debates we’ve had, defined it as an era of “late-stage counterrevolution”, which highlights that this counterrevolution is increasingly worn down historically.

Host: Beyond this, there’s an irresolvable antagonism between the valorization needs of capital, which are increasingly in crisis, and the reproduction of the proletariat as a global class, and this inevitably leads it to be constantly fighting and having to defend its own needs as a class. This stands out to me because, in a way, it exposes the need to learn from these struggles and these experiences. I also think it’s very valuable for grasping what you were saying: how important this global character of the proletariat in struggle is, how these struggles have fed each other in these latest waves, and this simultaneous and mimetic character too; and that capital is global, which is different from the reality of 1917, when capitalism had very different modes of action from today.

Nowadays it’s easier for these kinds of moments to be coordinated; when they have spontaneity and a class character, they have the capacity to act in a single direction, even though they’re often trapped in this counterrevolution. Still, I think this tendency to generalize the struggle, to expand and go beyond the framework of the institutions and the old forms of capitalist recuperation, that is, recuperation through trade unions or political parties, tells us that we ought to draw our own conclusions, get out of this loop and learn.

Question: can these waves of revolts turn into a revolutionary process?

Guest: This is a very open question, and an especially complex one. It doesn’t have an immediate answer; it depends on how we understand our current historical period. If we speak in terms of a snapshot of the present moment, I’ll come back to this later. First, from a broader historical perspective, the answer is a definite yes. Our role as revolutionaries is to help with this kind of vectorization in these struggles and revolts.

But before anything else, it’s very interesting how you’ve gathered a whole series of issues from what I was saying earlier, and there are new aspects you’ve introduced that I find important. Firstly, we’re at a stage of capitalist development in which the problems in capital’s valorization process are increasingly acute. We’ve developed this issue in various texts; I’m thinking of the last book we wrote on imperialism. These difficulties in the capitalist valorization process are present in these kinds of struggles, because capital’s capacity to socialize and integrate them is increasingly limited compared with the past, and that’s a fundamental aspect if we’re to present and reflect on our historical moment.

It’s also enormously important because it explains not only that capitalism is global, as you said, but also that the proletariat is a global class, and that these waves are mimetic and in many cases feed off each other. Just think of the struggles happening right now in education, whether here, in France, Belgium, Albania or Portugal: beyond the unconscious process, these are struggles that feed off each other, and that’s fundamental to how we envision the future and the coming historical moment. So that’s a second aspect I find important.

The question you asked is very complex. I think it’s present implicitly, though not so much explicitly, in the materials we’ve produced so far. It’s important to think about historical moments in their diversity and in their differing importance. It’s not by accident that we say we live in a “hinge period”, nor that we speak of cycles of struggle, or waves. These aren’t accidental terms, because we’re talking about different historical periods.

At the bottom of this question, I believe it’s important to remember that capitalism, like all modes of production, is a historical era, and we want to put an end to it and to all the other historical eras that our historical comrades called the “prehistory of humanity”.

And as we said earlier, 1926, just to set a date but also because it marks the beginning of one of the counterrevolutions, the one that fed Stalinism with the imposition of “socialism in one country”, inaugurated a counterrevolutionary period in which we still live. But it’s also a period that has gone through different stages since the “midnight in the century” of the 1930s: from times when the counterrevolution crushed us completely to processes of erosion, like the struggles of the 1950s in Stalinist countries such as Hungary and Poland, and later in East Berlin, and especially in the 1960s and 1970s, when a strong process of erosion of the counterrevolution took place.

Nowadays we find ourselves in a late-stage counterrevolutionary period, characterized by a “hinge period” with a whole series of specific features, which I encourage anyone listening to read about, because, as we said earlier, it combines the crisis of the Stalinist counterrevolution with the tendency towards imperialist war and an ever-deepening crisis of capital, coexisting with ecological collapse.

One of the elements we’ve highlighted throughout this episode is that these kinds of struggles have yet to reach an inflection point at which they develop as a cycle with a pre-revolutionary or revolutionary character. As you mentioned, we’re far from getting there; these struggles are still maturing. And although 2001, 2006 and 2011 are now far behind us, and many of our comrades experienced those struggles first-hand, especially from 2011 onwards, and although we’re now far from the citizenism that infected the struggle of that time, at the same time we’re still far from a class perspective, a class maturation and a stronger class reality capable of inaugurating an era of revolutionary class struggle.

That will be the most important cycle yet, like past revolutionary cycles in the history of the proletariat, such as the one from 1917 to 1923, or 1927. If this new process comes about, especially in China, we hope its maturation will be able to open a new revolutionary cycle that leads us to the defeat of capitalism and inaugurates the “era of history”, as Marx and Engels said: communism.

That’s why I think it’s useful to think of this diversity of historical periods as a compass for locating ourselves in the historical time we’re in.

Host: And to have the capacity to read historical periods within a temporal dimension…

Guest: Exactly. I think it’s something that characterizes us, and we can develop it further later: having, as communists, a historical method that keeps us from being “impressionists” or activists is what allows us to understand our tasks and the historical moment we’re in. I think what we’ve said so far confirms that we were right: we’re not in a revolutionary period, and it will be a long time before we are, but neither are we in a period of social peace nor crushing counterrevolution. Our method has been fundamental in reaching these conclusions.

Host: This also connects with the next question, because in the end it’s this fighting proletariat which, over time (and we’ll have to look at it in this temporal dimension), can clarify itself and understand that through struggle it can cast off these counterrevolutionary forms, all these forces dragging it into the swamp, such as, often, nationalism or any struggle that comes from outside its own interests. This clarification will come about through the different moments and battles that will take place, and, as we said, they’ll increase in intensity, probably because capitalism won’t give us any peace and everything will become increasingly turbulent, due to the ecological crisis you mentioned or even the possibility of world war.

Different struggles will keep taking place, and through them consciousness will mature. We’re speaking of class consciousness, of a proletariat that struggles and constitutes itself as a class, and it will take a long time. It won’t be immediate, as we’ve already said, and we can’t expect it to be. We also have to see that maturation and change happen through struggle: it’s the reality of struggle that allows consciousness to mature and makes it possible to erect a revolution. In any case, these are times that will come and for which we are preparing. The question is: what elements of progress, or what limits, does the proletariat express today at a global level?

Guest: This is another interesting question to think about, along with what you were mentioning before. Before I answer, I’d like to reflect on something written by a comrade of ours, in fact in the last text she wrote before she was murdered by the alliance of social democracy and fascism. Rosa Luxemburg said: “from defeat to defeat until the final victory”. And that’s because, as another comrade also said, the proletariat is a class that has “nothing to lose but our chains”, chains that bind us to this world. We have nothing to gain in this world, and we can only learn through our defeats that there’s nothing to conquer within this world and this society, contrary to what social democracy and the left or far left of capital claim. We can only learn from defeats.

And we find a really important element in the text we mentioned on the historical period: the crisis of the counterrevolution. That’s why we speak of a late-stage counterrevolution, and why we’re able to speak of it at all: because it concerns the historical experience of the proletariat. That is to say, when it was midnight in the century. Deep down, what a counterrevolution means is that a historical era closes, because the different historical experiences become completely chained to counterrevolutionary processes, to the historical trinity of social democracy, fascism and Stalinism.

The historical experience of capitalist brutality during the imperialist war of 1939–45 would be chained to citizenist, antifascist, nationalist and democratic logics that prevent this historical experience from opening up to the advance of the proletariat as such.

It’s important to understand that this has been broken: we’re facing a cycle of protests that is allowing the proletariat, and effectively so, to learn from its own historical experience. The problem is that it is learning from that experience having lived under total counterrevolution, under the weight that electoral cycles, citizenism, nationalism and different forms of leftism still carry. That’s why it’s important to reflect on the historical period we’re living in, on the scale of decades, as you were saying.

At the same time, the development of the proletariat’s consciousness, defined by the historical determinations of capitalism and its crisis, comes about in an uneven and combined way, just like capitalism’s own development. It’s very important to understand that we’re witnessing a subterranean maturation among hundreds of thousands of young proletarians worldwide who, both unconsciously and consciously, are experiencing that this world is not only exhausted but that a revolutionary alternative must be sought, contrary to what all those leftist academics have been saying: that capitalism is ending but we can’t even imagine an alternative to it. That belonged to a previous historical moment, the one 10 or 15 years ago, which clearly no longer exists. We’ll talk about this in depth later, and about how this defines what our tasks are.

It’s also important to recognize a whole series of limitations we’ve already seen in these struggles. Firstly, they have to do with the fact that the proletariat still doesn’t appear as a political class; we’re still far from that. But these kinds of historical experiences are what will determine the emergence of the proletariat as a class and, ultimately, the development of revolutionary processes that, as our historical current puts it, reverse the praxis of capital. In the short term, though, what is actually happening, unevenly and obviously still heavily infected by the ideologies of the far left of capital, is a process of maturation among sectors of (not only, but especially) young proletarians who are searching for an alternative, and this is part of our characterization of the historical moment.

Host: Yeah, we really are far from living through revolutionary situations, but it’s important to look at the dynamic of this “arrow of time” in light of the current conjuncture. We also can’t confuse circumstances with facts when reading our historical moment; that’s why I think it’s important to speak of a “hinge moment”, which we can talk more about later.

But something comes to mind as we speak of this view of a time in the making, of subterranean maturation. We’re in a historical moment that will inevitably create historical bifurcations that make this possible. There will be, there will have to be, a revolutionary class movement in the future, with a fully matured consciousness. Right now, though, this implies a possibility: through all these waves, through everything, a fighting proletariat is being generated, without full consciousness of a revolutionary program but on that path, and it is generating this historical bifurcation that will make it possible at some point, right?

And what caught my attention is how these social accelerators, these fuels we mentioned before (climate change, war, a world without meaning). For example, all these people, all these groups, all these young people who see no future. This is really important with regard to the meaninglessness that we too experience, because there’s an ever-present antagonism that will produce class struggle, even though it currently lacks a body, in the form of a revolutionary party. Nevertheless, it’s preparing itself for that.

I found this important because we take up that tradition, that vector, that idea, and bring in that reading. That’s where we have to understand our role as revolutionary minorities in these kinds of processes, which still lack that clarity or are, let’s say, not yet at that stage, because historically we aren’t at that stage yet.

Guest: Of course, totally. Once again, the introduction you made to the question is really important, because it contains a central element for us. As we always say, communism is a real movement, and the fact that it’s a real movement has a lot to do with that first concept, “the arrow of time”: capitalism, in its contradictory and dialectical development, prepares communism as a real movement.

And today communism is the only historical possibility in which we can live with the enormous level of complexity and development of the productive forces in a way that is not catastrophic and does not lead to the extinction of our species and of humanity. This arrow of time leads us into ever-deeper crises of capital and ever-stronger explosions of social struggle, which, as we’ve said, will feed into one another and have something “evolutionary” about them.

That is to say, in the same way that the human species evolved and grew because it needed to equip itself, through cooperation, with instruments, qualities, faculties and organs in order to survive and develop as a species, today we’ve reached an evolutionary phase of humanity in which communism is the movement that will allow not only the survival of our species, as happened in class societies, but also a true life as a species. That’s why communism is a plan of life for the species. And we’re heading towards a historical bifurcation that leads either to our extinction or to communism as this plan of life for the species.

So, we find that this development of historical bifurcations, as we’ve set out in texts such as the one on the reversal of praxis, and as our historical current and other comrades such as n+1 have done, involves breaking with the dualism between communist revolutionaries and the class. Unlike for leftism, as Trotsky said in 1938, “the historical crisis of mankind is the crisis of the revolutionary leadership”. NO, if there’s no revolutionary situation, there’s no revolutionary leadership; if the class hasn’t built a party, if it hasn’t secreted a real party as the leading organ of the class, then there’s no revolutionary situation. That’s why we’re still far from that historical period, and that’s why there’s no dualism.

But this doesn’t mean that we, as revolutionary minorities, as groups, don’t have an active role to play in these cycles of struggle, protest and revolt, and we’re certainly trying to play it! I think it’s something all our comrades are trying to do at this moment.

And today it’s fundamental to understand that our tasks as communists are always invariant, and it’s really important at this historical moment that we have the capacity to connect with the most radical sectors of the struggles worldwide. We have global tasks of great importance, because the party must be global, in order to help establish these processes of clarification and decantation from a political, organizational and programmatic point of view.

The great task we have ahead of us at a global level is developing discussions with many comrades in Latin America, the USA, Australia, Belgium, Italy and wherever possible. What matters is not just how we centralize these struggles and experiences, but also how we locate them in historical time and try to think about them from the intransigence characteristic of us communists, from the continuity of the red thread that constitutes our historical program, our historical party.

Host: Let’s thank our comrade for their time and for all this work. Thanks a lot.

Guest: Thank you all. It’s always a pleasure to be able to discuss things here among ourselves.

Host: Absolutely. And just to remind everyone of the materials that can be useful for going deeper into this discussion, materials we’ve written, produced and distributed: Not Only Paris Burns, Ten Notes on the Revolutionary Perspective, Capitalist Catastrophe and Revolutionary Theory, and Notes on Our Historical Moment; as well as a text by our comrades of n+1, “A Life Without Meaning”. You can also find us on Telegram, Facebook and Twitter as “Group Barbaria”, and on our website, barbaria.net. Greetings, and see you in the struggle!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *